Ce site Web a des limites de navigation. Il est recommandé d'utiliser un navigateur comme Edge, Chrome, Safari ou Firefox.

Taylor Made

Only the wily Pam Tanowitz would take Franz Schubert’s dark meditation on mortality, the “Death and the Maiden” string quartet, and turn it into a bright Seussian romp. Her new dance for the Paul Taylor Dance Company, “Messengers, Maidens and the End of Something Else,” was easily the most upbeat work on the bill last Saturday at the David H. Koch Theater, which also included Taylor’s twisted “…Byzantium” and Robert Battle’s fascistic “No Longer Silent,” a company premiere.

Performance

Paul Taylor Dance Company: “Messengers, Maidens and the End of Something Else” by Pam Tanowitz / “…Byzantium” by Paul Taylor / “No Longer Silent” by Robert Battle

Place

David H. Koch Theater, Lincoln Center, New York, November 14, 2026

Words

Faye Arthurs

Pam Tanowitz's “Messengers, Maidens and the End of Something Else.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

Schubert, 27, was processing his terminal syphilis diagnosis when he wrote his String Quartet No. 14 in D minor in 1824. He died four years later, before the work premiered, but it has since become one of the most famous pieces of chamber music. Tanowitz is no stranger to teasing out the histories of iconic scores and texts; she has worked with Beethoven’s “Pastoral,” T.S. Eliot’s “Four Quartets,” and the “Song of Songs” from the Bible. But this new dance demonstrated an interesting departure from source material fealty. In “Messengers,” Tanowitz and her team of frequent collaborators: the painter Sarah Crowner, the costumers Reid Bartelme and Harriet Jung, and the lighting designer Brandon Stirling Baker, largely ignored the grim reaper overtones.

The curtain rose to display Crowner’s colorful, stacked wings. At a Guggenheim Works & Process event in September, Crowner explained that these were inspired by the storage racks of paintings in her own studio. Almost each wing was filled with a dancer in a matching color, as if they were in scenery camouflage. Maybe they each stepped out of a different “Death and the Maiden” painting, as it is such a common trope in visual art. The women wore various yellow shades, and the supporting men wore gradations of red. Lee Duveneck, the lead, was the lone dancer in a green hue. This vibrant tableau was anything but morose, though one of Duveneck’s first moves was to splat on his tummy.

Was he the Maiden? If there was any connection to death, it was in Tanowitz’s exploration of dancerly repose—a theme she was also playing with in her recent pièce d’occasion for Adrian Danchig-Waring’s farewell to the New York City Ballet, “Once With You.” In that dance, which premiered three weeks prior to “Messengers,” she had three women waiting around—both standing and sitting—as casually as they would in a rehearsal. It was startling to see such laxness in performance, as most stage resting isn’t restful at all. (Ask any courtier in a full-length ballet about calf, neck, hip, and back cramps. And supposedly, one of the hardest parts of the titular role in Balanchine’s “Apollo” is looking comfortable on that tiny stool).

Pam Tanowitz's “Messengers, Maidens and the End of Something Else.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

Pam Tanowitz's “Messengers, Maidens and the End of Something Else.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

“Once with You” provided a taste of ballet bodies in idle; in this latest dance, Tanowitz worked through every possible manner of onstage reclining (including sitting at the front of the stage with legs dangling into the orchestra pit and lying in puppy piles, heads on each other’s hipbones). I had never thought much before about how, when one’s butt is firmly planted, leaning on a forearm signifies a completely different thing than leaning on a palm. In a wonderful segment, Duveneck, propped on the floor like Adam in the clouds on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, kept frantically scooting himself forward then returning to that Michelangelo posture. His attentiveness and frantic propulsions were at hilarious odds with the inert (literally pre-animate) pose.  

It seems to me like Tanowitz is sifting through layers of performativity these days. She has always been interested in this, and her own dancers are expert anti-showmen. At the Works & Process lecture, Tanowitz kept nudging Duveneck in this direction as she coached his solo: “don’t perform, make it a task,” she instructed. But lately she seems to be trying to force that neutrality upon the steps themselves, which is fascinating.  

In this vein, “Messengers” also contained numerous ballottés. These presentational, seesawing jump kicks were often done with a puffed-up chest (as they usually are in ballet) and proud, hands-on-hips port de bras. But then, Tanowitz also had Duveneck do ballotés just as aggressively in the legs, but with his fingertips grazing his shoulders and his elbows hunching together. This soft, protective, inward shape of his upper body was in such contrast with his lower half that I bet it was very hard to execute.

Tanowitz also curiously set ballottés at Crowner’s curlicued, red ballet barre, which looked like a cross between a Wump and a Zizzer Zazzer Zuzz (meaning a lumpy, whimsical form with a flamelike tail, if you don’t have small children at home). Ballottés are not really a barre step, as they are a medium jump featuring a significant weight shift. They are more often done in the center portion of a ballet class. (Barre work is about establishing one’s center line, where center work is about moving off it.) Indeed, when the dancers ballottéd, Crowner’s barre swayed along with the dancers’ rocking bodies. But that underlined another of this ballet’s witty jokes: a barre is the epitome of stabilization in ballet, but this one was destabilizing.     

Just as Tanowitz set a center step at the barre, she set a classic barre stance in the center. As far as I could tell, nobody in the cast put their leg up on Crowner’s trippy barre for a supported stretch (and likely they couldn’t, given the apparatus’s roller coaster dips). Yet, a few times, Tanowitz had Emmy Wildermuth resting her leg in à la seconde on a castmate as if they were her barre. Tanowitz and Crowner have claimed that they incorporated a barre as an ode to “Sunset,” one of Taylor’s many collaborations with the artist Alex Katz (a fruitful bond nicely echoed by their own partnership). “I do also lie when I write things about dances” Tanowitz impishly confessed at the Guggenheim. Whatever the reason, Crowner’s sculpture gave Tanowitz an opportunity to monkey around with barre culture. 

Duveneck draped himself forward over the bar for a spell, which dancers do all the time to decompress their spines. But Duveneck was dramatically arranged and lifeless in his hang, as if he’d been shot while climbing a fence. (Perhaps you could count this as his second maidenly death?) Another humorous moment had Jessica Ferretti and Elizabeth Chapa lying underneath the bar with their legs in the air. This is a standard dancer retreat during five-minute breaks, but only when the barres are attached to walls, upon which dancers can rest their legs to drain the blood and swelling from their feet.                           

Duveneck also reclined underneath the barre like a God and watched the three women in what appeared to be a nod to Balanchine: with female trio quotes from both “Apollo” and “Serenade,” two fateful ballets—particularly the latter, which features a Dark Angel who escorts a doomed woman to the afterlife. (Tanowitz had used snippets of similar imagery in “Once with You” as well.)  But “Messengers, Maidens, and the End of Something Else” only flirted with tragedy. Much of the time, the cast engaged in zesty little jigs, bouncy pony steps, and funny little thigh slaps that had them resembling a flock of penguins.

Patrick Gamble and Payton Primer in Paul Taylor's “ ... Byzantium.” Photograph by Ron Thiele

Patrick Gamble and Payton Primer in Paul Taylor's “ ... Byzantium.” Photograph by Ron Thiele

And “Messengers” ended on a zippy note, as the dancers lined up with chorus line precision and Duveneck gave a final arm flourish before freezing on the last note. Tanowitz explained at the Guggenheim that though the phrase the “End of Something Else” sounded portentous, it was meant literally: she had simply included the closing phrase from another dance somewhere in this one.

This dance was brilliantly followed by Taylor’s “…Byzantium,” which pointedly tackles the end of something: civilization. Though the title and movement headers (the first section is called “Passing,” the second “Past,” and the third is “To Come”) are taken from William Butler Yeats’s poem “Sailing to Byzantium” about the fall of the Byzantine Empire, David Gropman’s distorted American flag backdrops make it clear that Taylor implicates a much more recent society as well. The ballet was made in 1984 and hadn’t run since 2014. I applaud PTDC artistic director Michael Novak for his foresight in pulling it out now. I happened to see it in a week that saw widescale collapses at Microsoft and the FAA, gulp.

Taylor’s oeuvre swings between light and dark, and “…Byzantium” is one of his darkest. To Edgar Varèse’s unsettling soundtrack of eerie reeds and assaulting horns, dancers flail, convulse, and copulate while doing truly inventive moves. Taylor devised one-kneed crawls, dangerous leapfrogs, crotch slaps, skewed crucifix lifts, wrestling holds, and a clipped-wing motif. The second movement, “Past,” shifts gears as a quartet of priests (or saints?) in gilt robes (the excellent costumes are by William Ivey Long) perform calm, ritualistic movements to solo flute strains. (Varese’s “Density 21.5” was beautifully performed by Elizabeth Mann, and the Orchestra of St. Luke’s, conducted by David LaMarche, sounded wonderful all night). The icons practiced two finger benedictions and doled out imaginary wafers in between duck walks and flexed feet jigs that communed with Tanowitz’s opener.

In the last movement, “To Come,” Austin Kelly convulsed and impressively crab walked with just one arm before the entire cast spazzed out and crashed to the ground. Sinners and saints alike were felled to a brass section blowout. Patrick Gamble was incredible in this piece—and everything else on the program.

John Harnage and company in Robert Battle's “No Longer Silent.” Photograph by Jason Chuang

John Harnage and company in Robert Battle's “No Longer Silent.” Photograph by Jason Chuang

Robert Battle’s “No Longer Silent” was also squarely set in the dark zone. Battle was appointed a resident choreographer with the PTDC last year, after a long tenure as the artistic director of the Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater. I missed his world premiere this season, but the choice to bring his “No Longer Silent” into the Taylor rep at this moment was inspired.  (The ballet was choreographed on the Juilliard School in 2007 and added to the AAADT’s repertory in 2015.)

“No Longer Silent” was in deep conversation with “…Byzantium.” Both employed anxious, woodwind-and-brass heavy scores that were created in the 1920s. Battle’s work is set to the Nazi-banned “Ogelala,” by the Jewish composer Erwin Schulhoff, who died in a concentration camp. Though both dances depicted the moral dissolution of society, they went about it in different ways. Taylor chose a menacing, mystical route, with solo passages of disturbing specificity—thereby exposing human culture as a freak show.

Battle went militaristic, leaning into the chilling inhumanity of unison work for his large cast of 16. His tornado-like running circles evoked several versions of “The Rite of Spring,” which underlined his theme of groupthink murder. Some of the chugs, squats, and open-palmed hands beating the air came from African dance, but the dancers’ tailored black suits (by Fritz Masten) made the piece feel more corporate than tribal. It was as if Martha Graham’s “Steps in the Street” was being performed by agents in “The Matrix.” Given the current fears of A.I. consciousness, Battle’s nearly 20-year-old work felt remarkably prescient. This was not an easy night at the theater, but it was a timely and great one.

Faye Arthurs


Faye Arthurs is a former ballet dancer with New York City Ballet. She chronicled her time as a professional dancer in her blog Thoughts from the Paint. She graduated summa cum laude with a B.A. in English from Fordham University. She lives in Brooklyn with her partner and their sons.

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

comments

Veuillez noter que les commentaires doivent être approvés avant d'être affichés

Featured

Taylor Made
REVIEWS | Faye Arthurs

Taylor Made

Only the wily Pam Tanowitz would take Franz Schubert’s dark meditation on mortality, the “Death and the Maiden” string quartet, and turn it into a bright Seussian romp.

Plus
Head in the Clouds
INTERVIEWS | Victoria Looseleaf

Head in the Clouds

It’s not every day that a dance company can draw a crowd of nearly 50,000, but that’s precisely what Cloud Gate Dance Theater, the first and oldest known dance troupe in the Chinese-speaking world, did when performing outdoors in Taipei, Taiwan, in 2019.

Plus
Turning Back Time
REVIEWS | Karen Hildebrand

Turning Back Time

I’ve been looking forward to Cynthia Oliver’s latest work, yet I arrive to the show dubious about its topic. Do we really need another pandemic piece? Especially given this day of celebration after the 2026 midterm elections.

Plus
A Dance around the Table with Cherrie Yu
INTERVIEWS | Steven Vargas

A Dance around the Table with Cherrie Yu

A ping pong ball rhythmically bops back and forth, paddle to paddle. The hollow tap echoes, and the performers respond around the table, reframing the table tennis player’s swings and steps as a dance found in everyday life. 

Plus
Good Subscription Agency