This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Defining Connection

In a series called “Just Dance” on Nowness—a site I sometimes visit to see what’s up in the world of “genre busting” dance films that make it onto this stylized platform—I sometimes find little gems that quietly rock my world. Such is the case with What We Were, by director Kate Collins and choreographer Evan Sagadencky. With its gentle humanity and a story told entirely through movement, this for me is an exemplary representation of what the marriage of dance and cinema can do beautifully.

Performance

What We Were directed by Kate Collins and choreographed by Evan Sagadencky

Place

Nowness

Words

Sarah Elgart

Sagadencky and Dan Santiago in What We Were, a film by Kate Collins

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

We see two young men (Sagadencky and Dan Santiago) waiting for the train on a Dumbo (Brooklyn) subway platform. Santiago—hooked up to a pair of headphones—is visibly feeling the groove of a tune we cannot hear as viewers. His feet move just a bit . . . he’s clearly holding back. Sagadencky watches him with understanding and the familiarity of someone who has been there. And as the two strangers make eye contact the hint of something more is insinuated with a barely there smile exchanged between them. Moments later, we’re on the train with the two seated opposite each other, and what ensues is a series of vignettes in which dance is at once the vehicle for telling the story, and a big part of the story itself. 

Similarly to Celine Song’s film Past Lives, the director and choreographer herein are exploring the Korean concept of inyeon, or fate. Inspired by the myriad of daily interactions and small moments of exchange between otherwise total strangers that take place daily in New York City, or likely in any large metropolitan center, this film uses dance to mine the potential for a greater connection between two men each passing through their day.

Sagadencky and Dan Santiago in What We Were, a film by Kate Collins

The dance begins gently with men seated next to each other in front of a window looking onto a carousel, with the raising other of a foot, partially an invitation into playfulness, part flirtation, all “conversation.” The choreography—although rooted in contemporary dance language—has a healthy mix of B Boy-like moves as well as entangled limbs reminiscent of Rauf Yasit’s Rubberlegz. There is an ample use of gesture and weight-sharing as we follow them along, sometimes one dancer “listening” as the other “speaks.” The camera is always moving, which gives us as viewers a deeper sense of the passage of time and also ups our engagement into the two men and to the story. The locations are beautiful, and the color is lush, further drawing us into the romance of the film. The exchange and connection that emerges between them is delivered entirely through dance—a conversation, an exchange of experiences, and a sharing of who they are as individuals, entirely through movement. The beautiful score is ambient and instrumental—no hard hitting rhythms that the dance rides literally—and like the two dancers the score’s relationship to the choreography is autonomous yet completely sympathetic, and to this viewer, really beautiful.

At the end, we see they are still on the train, and we are left wondering if this is a hint of what is to come, or what might have been . . . and perhaps, the road not taken. Enjoy.

Sarah Elgart


Sarah Elgart is an award winning choreographer, director, movement director, and producer, creating original content for stage, site and screen, whose work has been seen internationally. Sarah’s ScreenDance Diaries is one of the first articles on the genre of Dance Film (originally for Cultural Daily). An alumna of the Sundance Institute’s Dance/Film Lab, AFI’s DWW, and a director member of the DGA, Sarah is Founder/Director of DARE TO DANCE IN PUBLIC FILM FESTIVAL (www.dare2danceinpublic.com). @arrogantelbow @dare2danceinpublic

comments

Featured

Defining Connection
Screen Dance | Sarah Elgart

Defining Connection

In a series called “Just Dance” on Nowness—a site I sometimes visit to see what’s up in the world of “genre busting” dance films that make it onto this stylized platform—I sometimes find little gems that quietly rock my world.

Continue Reading
Complex Female Characters
REVIEWS | Rebecca Deczynski

Complex Female Characters

When Richard Move enters from stage left, his presence is already monumental. In a long-sleeved gown, a wig swept in a dramatic topknot, and his eyes lined in striking swoops, the artist presents himself in the likeness of Martha Graham—though standing at 6’4, he has more than a foot on the late modern dance pioneer.  

Continue Reading
Ultimate Release
REVIEWS | Steven Sucato

Ultimate Release

Perhaps not since Mikhail Fokine’s 1905 iconic “The Dying Swan” has there been as haunting a solo dance depiction of avian death as Aakash Odedra Company’s “Songs of the Bulbul” (2024).

Continue Reading
Good Subscription Agency