This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Subversions of the Ideal

There’s a palpable intent to the swerving compositions of Pam Tanowitz’s “Pastoral:” the mannered choreography, with its long, soft angles and consciously discursive phrasing; the modest delivery of these rambles too, which are reined in, the spotlight for virtuosity wryly denied. The dancing unfolds to a wandering soundscape from Caroline Shaw, whose sly deconstruction of Beethoven’s ‘Pastoral’ symphony (aka No.6) repeatedly unsettles its own rhythms and harmonies. Meanwhile, the arcing geometries of Sarah Crowner’s set gust in and out of view, petals of pink and green. Disruption is a defining motif here. Instead of endings, beginnings seem to shepherd in more beginnings.

Performance

Pam Tanowitz Dance: “Pastoral”

Place

Barbican Centre, London, UK, October 1, 2026

Words

Sara Veale

Pam Tanowitz Dance in “Pastoral.” Photograph by Lawrence Sumulong

There are a lot of components to take in across the hour-long work, and while each is bright with focus, only a few sections gripped me with their sum effect. I couldn’t quite grasp the shape of it, never knowing where I was outside of the immediate moment. Perhaps that’s the point—the ‘pastoral,’ at least in the sense that the masters apprehended it, with its visions of harmony and perfection, is inherently elusive, rooted in myth, maybe even a fiction. The pleasantries here certainly elude. They roam, magnify, double back on themselves and very often dissolve into something peculiar, sometimes to stirring effect: a tiny gallop into open arms; a quivering pose that hums like a tableau vivant. Even the costumes, fetching bodysuits in pastel colourways, change register as lilacs and corals collide.

The deliberate imprecision of the dancing is behind these highlights—sprightly gusts of action with a bounce and timing that are ever so slightly fudged. Tanowitz evokes some of the quainter hallmarks of mid-century American modern dance—the pedestrian strides and trots; the simple leaps, hands in a V; the androgynous co-ed ensemble—while unfastening them from their symmetry. Movements continue beyond the music accompanying them. Pert piques and other balletic acts are destabilised by windmilling arms; balances drop and jumps land off-kilter. Bent-kneed toe walking reads especially eerie on gangly Marc Crousillat. 

Pam Tanowitz Dance in “Pastoral.” Photograph by Lawrence Sumulong

Pam Tanowitz Dance in “Pastoral.” Photograph by Lawrence Sumulong

There’s an air of chance to it all, not in the sense that’s it’s unfolding randomly, Cunningham-style, but that Tanowitz perhaps seized on spontaneity to create it, setting each section as it arrived to her, without much fuss over the broader form. The fluidity and unpredictability are refreshing at times and disaffecting at others.

Things are unsettled further with Shaw’s busy score, which mingles discordant woodwinds (played live by three musicians) with recordings of Beethoven proper piped in alongside clips of thunder, traffic and insect choruses. Andrew Nogal’s oboe offers animal croaks, while Dana Jessen puts down her bassoon to make kazoo-like bird calls with her own mouth. A large cloak lies draped at the edge of the stage, undisturbed until the final sequences, when the ensemble drags it into play. Bright lights are swapped for amber slants as painted curtains drawn new divisions across the stage—summer giving way to the fall, perhaps. Here, as with the dance, the ideal is subverted with something oblique and uncanny.

Pam Tanowitz Dance in “Pastoral.” Photograph by Lawrence Sumulong

Pam Tanowitz Dance in “Pastoral.” Photograph by Lawrence Sumulong

At some point, gradually so, the seven dancers move beyond abstraction and start conversing with each other. Increasingly, they live in their movements and their communion, firing off bigger leaps and higher, sturdier extensions. Even in these louder moments, a certain coolness prevails. There are no fireworks, no romances or yearning hearts, just people moving in all their banality and all their majesty.

Sara Veale


Sara Veale is a London-based writer and editor. She's a member of the UK Dance Critics' Circle and has written about dance for the Observer, the Spectator, Harper's Bazaar, Auditorium, Gramophone and more. Her book, Wild Grace: The Untamed Women of Modern Dance, was published by Faber in 2025.

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

comments

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Featured

Good Subscription Agency