This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Shakespearean Twist

It’s a drag to report that I had the urge to walk out of my first performance back in NYC after a long summer break. So much for feeling refreshed. The culprit was the Boston Ballet’s rendition of Akram Kahn’s “Vertical Road (Reimagined) 2023,” which closed the second program of New York City Center’s annual Fall for Dance Festival. Yet, happily, I can also announce the addition of a promising new voice to the choreographic scene: that of Robbie Fairchild, the ballet and Broadway star. Programming disparity is the perennial gamble of Fall for Dance, now in its 23rd year. The wide-ranging and affordably priced festival allows artists and companies to take risks—which means that some riskiness naturally trickles into the audience experience too.    

Performance

Fall for Dance Festival Program 2: Philadanco! in Juel D. Lane’s “Heirborne (my mama ain’t never touched the sky, but she gave me wings)” / Boston Ballet in Akram Kahn’s “Vertical Road (Reimagined) 2023” / “Lord Chamberlain’s Men” by Robbie Fairchild

Place

New York City Center, New York, NY, September 24, 2026

Words

Faye Arthurs

“Lord Chamberlain’s Men” by Robbie Fairchild. Photograph by Steven Pisano

On the other hand, the evening commenced with a Philadanco! offering that was risk-averse in every way, exemplified by the dancers’ numerous rotations that fell into a hazy middle ground between flat-footed promenades and turns on relevé. However, Juel D. Lane’s “Heirborne (my mama ain’t never touched the sky, but she gave me wings)” was impressively athletic even if it was not otherwise revolutionary. The octet of performers moved in tidy unison blocks to a mélange of thumping musical compositions and remixes by various artists including RAHBI, Bruce Rayburn, and Leo Ra Soul. Likewise, Lane blended contemporary, African, ballet, and hip hop styles.  

I liked when the dancers fist-bumped their own knees. And I’m always content to watch people luxuriate in arabesque, which Lane had his cast doing often—with neat sideways back cranks at the end. These touches helped counter the fact that this dance, which premiered last December on the troupe’s home turf in Philadelphia, was replete with the murky lighting, spotlit solos in silence, throbbing tunes and jet plane noises plaguing the contemporary genre of late. The worst trap it fell into, however, was that its first-person title invoked a seemingly personal and meaningful idea that was unaddressed by all the darkly lit (by Nick Kolin), anonymous group dancing. The capable performers displayed their personalities only in the curtain call, when they bowed one at a time with spontaneous boogies. 

At the end of the night, Kahn took contemporary fads to the extreme. “Vertical Road” opened with whooshing sounds on a dark stage, as if the setting were a wind tunnel. In between bouts of tortured floorwork, Boston Ballet star principal Jeffrey Cirio brushed dust off the shoulders of a statuesque woman in toga-like drapery. A wedge of dancers in the same ivory garb came to life with a powdery eruption. Kahn’s stagecraft is often elaborate and powerful, and this talcum-flying prologue was cool (though why no dust blew off the cast throughout all the windstorms is a mystery). The production team included Kimie Nakano (costumes), Jesper Kongshaug (lighting), and the Ruth Little (dramaturg).  

This introduction seemed to evoke the terracotta armies of antiquity, or other ancient peoples, in the vein of Baye & Asa’s “Cortege” for the Martha Graham Dance Company, which had coincidentally closed the first program of the FFDF. However, this possible plotline lost steam as the piece gave over to teams of dancers pulsing in unison in the darkness for what seemed to be an eternity. The score, by Nitin Sawhney, was essentially a metronome with slight varying in instrumentation. Cirio appeared to die a few times, and he and others often flopped on the ground like fish out of water. The glimpses of Kahn’s Kathak influences and signature crown hands were welcome. Less so tired trends like silent screams, hive mind conjuring, and squat squads. 

Kahn deployed alien encounter imagery for the dance’s labored ending. Cirio touched palms with the statuesque woman, who was now silhouetted behind a membrane backlit by a sallow orb. The corps reentered after her, trailing their hands across the barrier in a slow march. Cirio mid-fived each one in turn as they made their interminable procession. In the last moments, the piece made a stab at religiosity, as a smoke machine (which was distractingly audible long before its billows became visual) produced cloudy whorls, and at the touch of Cirio’s hand the scrim fell. On Kahn’s website, “Vertical Road” is described as “a meditation on the journey from gravity to grace. It explores humanity’s earthly nature, rituals, and the consequences of our actions.” Oh, just that. Unfortunately, those grandiose themes did not register; and the choreography was thin and repetitive.  

Boston Ballet in Akram Kahn’s “Vertical Road (Reimagined) 2023.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

Boston Ballet in Akram Kahn’s “Vertical Road (Reimagined) 2023.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

But I still left the theater on a bit of a back-to-school high, thanks to the middle ballet on the program, “Lord Chamberlain’s Men,” the choreographic debut of Robbie Fairchild. Though this co-commission with Guild Hall was perhaps the riskiest bit of festival programming, it proved to be a risk well worth taking. The work was a ballet/theater hybrid, performed by a superstar pickup troupe under the banner Robbie Fairchild’s Players. They were backed live by a terrific ensemble of musicians, led by music director Sean Peter Forte.  

Fairchild, who cast himself as William Shakespeare, probed the gray areas in the Bard’s biography through the lens of his own complicated sexual history—which involved various entrances and exits from the closet, conversion therapy, and a failed heterosexual marriage. Fairchild imagined Shakespeare as a kindred soulmate in repression. He questioned why Shakespeare wrote over a hundred love sonnets to an unspecified male youth, and he postulated that the forbidden romance of “Romeo and Juliet” had homoerotic underpinnings. Shakespeare worked in a time beholden to the Buggery Act of 1533, which prohibited sodomy, among other things. But his plays were performed by the all-male acting company Lord Chamberlain’s Men. So, though Elizabethan men were not allowed to love each other offstage, they were free to touch, kiss, and romance each other onstage.      

Authorial conspiracy theories are not the typical subject matter of ballets. I imagine that Balanchine’s famous witticism, “there are no mothers-in-law in ballet,” would certainly extend to cover, say, speculation about Elena Ferrante’s true identity. But Fairchild got his ideas across with astounding clarity. Perhaps this was because he surrounded himself with expert mentors, including Nicholas Hytner, Sonya Tayeh, and Christopher Wheeldon. But I suspect it had even more to do with his clever layering of mediums and the way he infused this dance with impassioned sincerity.              

Fairchild’s great conceit was to apply balletic canon to the Shakespearean canon. To set scenes from Shakespeare’s famous plays, Fairchild used music from the most famous ballets. Significantly, all the selections were by Tchaikovsky, an oft-closeted gay man who also tried and failed at marriage with a woman. The jaunty Diamond variation from “Sleeping Beauty” perfectly supported the witty love-hate courtship of “The Taming of the Shrew,” while the snaky Pas de Quatre music from “Swan Lake’s” third act was effectively repurposed to accompany sinister figures in black cloaks as they carried out a Buggery Act execution. Switching gears, Fairchild deftly employed a piano etude for the quietly tragic pas de deux between Shakespeare and his wife Anne Hathaway, danced by the superb Lauren Lovette (whom it is always a thrill to catch back onstage in pointe shoes). The rumbly, solo instrument nicely reflected their intimate, and turbulent, interaction. That Lovette and Fairchild both starred in the title roles of New York City Ballet’s “Romeo and Juliet”—and both broke off personal relationships with yet more Romeos and Juliets in other casts—added even more emotional texture to the work.   

Lauren Lovette and Robbie Fairchild in “Lord Chamberlain’s Men” by Fairchild. Photograph by Steven Pisano

Lauren Lovette and Robbie Fairchild in “Lord Chamberlain’s Men” by Fairchild. Photograph by Steven Pisano

Fairchild also pulled smartly from the choreographic canon. The most ardent pas de deux, for himself and the lithe Vincenzo Di Primo (as his Juliet and the presumed muse of the sonnets), hinted at Wheeldon’s extensive partnering oeuvre as well as Angelin Preljocaj’s “Le Parc.” And Fairchild quoted the best step from Act IV of Peter Martins’s “Swan Lake” verbatim: the partnered arabesque hop on pointe rolling in to a low jeté lift. This passage comes at the emotional climax of that ballet, so Fairchild’s use of it in his pas de deux with Lovette tapped into the despair and devotion wedded in that lakeside moment. Yet it also injected ironic distance, since Shakespeare and Hathaway were no longer a pair so in love that they would choose death together over a life apart, as Odette and Siegfried often do.  

Though Fairchild brilliantly translated Shakespeare’s literary milieu into the wordless realm of dance, he also wielded a script, which was co-written with the playwright Rick Elice. Almost all the lines went to Nico Greetham (equally impressive at dancing and acting), who broke the fourth wall as an omniscient narrator in the guise of Shakespeare’s impish best friend George. (He also portrayed the lecherous Lord Chamberlain in a few scenes.) Greetham’s George was a plucky fellow, even in the immediate aftermath of his beheading. In the final section of the ballet, Fairchild addressed the audience to explain that George was woven into the cultural fabric through the character of Mercutio.   

This poignant example got to the crux of the night’s lopsidedness. The other pieces purported grand themes, but they were rendered diffusely, so they never resonated. Fairchild, like Shakespeare, took the opposite approach, demonstrating how the specifics of a life could become universally influential. As Fairchild theorized that Shakespeare poured his difficult personal experiences into his works, he processed his own difficult personal experiences through this new work, thereby modeling the best aspects that art can offer: an endlessly nourishing cycle of connection, inspiration, and interpretation. Though it was already so textually rich, “Lord Chamberlain’s Men” was just a sketch. It was billed as a World Premiere Preview Presentation, and Fairchild has expressed hopes to expand it into a full-length work. In this case, I can’t wait to see more. 

Faye Arthurs


Faye Arthurs is a former ballet dancer with New York City Ballet. She chronicled her time as a professional dancer in her blog Thoughts from the Paint. She graduated summa cum laude with a B.A. in English from Fordham University. She lives in Brooklyn with her partner and their sons.

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

comments

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Featured

Leading the Pack
INTERVIEWS | Eoin Fenton

Leading the Pack

Things seem to be clicking in place for Mamela Nyamza. Her latest work “The Herd/Less” is touring the world while her recognition as a choreographer with a distinction for the subversive and political has earned her a Silver Lion for dance at the Venice Biennale.

Continue Reading
Good Subscription Agency