Ce site Web a des limites de navigation. Il est recommandé d'utiliser un navigateur comme Edge, Chrome, Safari ou Firefox.

Making a Statement

What is the friction between words and movement? What does one give us that the other doesn’t? If there is an intelligence in movement and physicality that cannot be expressed through words, do we look down on that intelligence?

Performance

Nederlands Dans Theater 1: “The Statement” by Crystal Pite

Place

Filmed in 2018 in co-production with Mezzo and La Belle Télé, directed by Tommy Pascal

Words

Róisín O'Brien

NDT1 perform Crystal Pite's “The Statement.” Photograph by Rahi Rezvani

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

While many choreographers might shy away from words, either out of a sense of loyalty to pure movement or an aversion to narrative, Crystal Pite and Jonathon Young happily collide the two worlds together. Pite has spoken of how language can open up new possibilities for her as a choreographer.

“The Statement” sees four officials in nondescript suits caught in the orbit of a monolithic central table, perhaps in a windowless room in the basement of some government or corporate building. Two of the characters are from a department where blame for a conflict, that is spiralling out of control, shall fall: the other two are there to get a crucial ‘statement.’

NDT perform “The Statement” by Crystal Pite. Rahi Rezvani

Guilt, accountability, and the (malevolent) opacity of bureaucratic structures are recurrent themes in Pite and Young’s collaborations. Halfway through the dance, as insinuation, provocation and on—and off—the record statements are bandied about through voiceovers, the stakes are upturned: one investigator is instead deemed the scapegoat.

In these fraught plays with Young, Pite works with everyday recognisable gestures: hands cradling bowed heads, arms pushing against protesting colleagues, backs arching in desperation. Pite breaks them down, isolates each beat; she repeats, backtracks, varies, and builds on each brick of movement. But the quality is also soft; feet sliding across the floor, limbs rippling into extensions. We see the bare bones of an expression, our very mechanics laid bare, but emotion is never lost. If anything, it is heightened, written in strained, emphatic strokes. The alternating and often surprising rhythm of the choreography is always breathtaking to watch.

NDT perform “The Statement” by Crystal Pite. Rahi Rezvani

There’s a risk that the themes of distortion and displacement in “The Statement” translates into an evasive script: a risk in showing a constant deferral of responsibility and an infinite web of unnamed deceit, which can lose sight of the particular reality that Pite and Young want to depict. Each dancer’s specific characterisation holds this at bay, particularly Aram Hasler’s guilt-ridden official. A brilliant sequence where all four lash and move with frenzied calculation at opposite sides of the table is chillingly officious, yet physically desperate.

I watched this performance online. We can all agree on the irreplaceable experience of a live performance but this piece, beautifully and conscientiously filmed by Tommy Pascal, does not suffer. If anything, seeing the increasingly pleading faces of the performers up close, their joints clicking into tortured configurations, only adds to the tension of this impressive work.

Róisín O'Brien


Róisín is a dance artist and writer based in Edinburgh, Scotland. She regularly writes for Springback Magazine, The Skinny and Seeing Dance, and has contributed to The Guardian and Film Stories. She loves being in the studio working on a new choreography with a group of dancers, or talking to brilliant people in the dance world about their projects and opinions. She tries not to spend too much time obsessing over Crystal Pite.

comments

Featured

Looking Back to See Forward
REVIEWS | Karen Greenspan

Looking Back to See Forward

I step off the elevator onto the 5th floor of the Whitney Museum and I am awed by the spectacle, vastness, and ground shifting power of the “Edges of Ailey” exhibition. This tribute to Alvin Ailey and his universe—past, present, and future—not only lifts up its larger-than-life subject but it also, like a great ocean wave, raises up and carries forward everything in its wake.

Plus
Paquita Bananas
REVIEWS | Faye Arthurs

Paquita Bananas

Marius Petipa’s “Paquita” Grand Pas Classique has been around since 1881. I last reviewed a version in 2023, by Les Ballets Trockadero de Monte Carlo.

Plus
Adrift
REVIEWS | Victoria Looseleaf

Adrift

While Kendrick Lamar performed “Humble,” during his Super Bowl halftime set and was surrounded by dancers clad in red, white and blue—and in the process assumed the formation of the American flag (choreographed by Charm La’Donna)—so, too, did Faye Driscoll use performers who created slews of shapes/sculptures in her astonishing work, “Weathering,” seen at REDCAT on February 8, the last of three sold-out performances.

Plus
Good Subscription Agency