Ce site Web a des limites de navigation. Il est recommandé d'utiliser un navigateur comme Edge, Chrome, Safari ou Firefox.

Creature Comforts

How do you translate a scent into dance? A poem? An illustration? In BalletCollective’s 15th anniversary season, the company’s ambition to push beyond expected parameters of ballet is expressed in three world-premiere works. In the nave of St. John the Divine, the troupe of dancers—a mix of contemporary artists and those more classically oriented—perform in the round and evoke all manner of creatures fantastical and freakish.

Performance

BalletCollective: “Brigid” by Noelle Kayser, Julie Kent, and Heather Sielaff / “The Wet Heat of Living” by Shane Urton / “What If, For a Day, We Could Be Friends” by Troy Schumacher /

Place

Cathedral of Saint John the Divine, New York, NY, November 3, 2026

Words

Rebecca Deczynski

Arayah Lyte, Mizuho Kappa, and Brooke Lutz in “The Wet Heat of Living” by Shane Urton. Photograph by Steven Pisano

For its choreographic commissions, BalletCollective starts with a phrase, which it presents to a choreographer, composer, and Source Artist—the latter of whom works in a medium far outside the realm of dance. These collaborations around this year’s phrase, “opposites attract,” resulted in three ballets in which, to varying degrees, the dancers play with opposition and contrasts as driving tensions in their interactions with one another. 

“Brigid,” the first piece, is a collaboration between choreographer Noelle Kayser, composer and cellist Julie Kent, and perfumer Heather Sielaff, who created a forest-like fragrance inspired by the Celtic goddess. Across a shadowy stage, dappled with light like a forest floor, three dancers move sinuously, as if underwater. Georgia Greene, transitioning between tilts, penchés, and needles, has immense control of her liquid movement, and in the rhythmless score, the contemporary dancers find impressive harmony. The most satisfying moments come when the trio expands to five dancers—Greene, plus Thomas Hogan, Mizuho Kappa, Arayah Luyte, and Alexsander Swader—and they cross through one another. There’s an almost baucchic quality to the way they jostle forward, feet flexed and arms shrugged upward.

After this first movement, the classical dancers—Maya Milić, Alexander Perone, Davide Riccardo, Keenan Kiefer, and Ella Titus—have their moment. Where the contemporary dancers were fluid and slippery, these performers have a slightly more staccato attack to their angular poses. Milić and Titus, both on pointe, revolve in développés and arabesques, sometimes rotating on their axis while held by two different partners. At times, there is a gymnastic effect to the way they tumble through the air. 

For the last movement of the piece—the stage lighting now a golden hue—the contemporary dancers return, bending and swirling, moving between control and chaos. They close the work, walking slowly the lights fade to black. 

It’s clear that this cast of dancers is exceptionally strong, and each particularly skilled in their preferred mode of training. What this work exposes, though, is a challenge that BalletCollective faces across its repertoire: it is difficult to bring together dancers of different disciplines while creating a work that is cohesive. The dichotomy between the contemporary and the more classical dancers does not quite feel like a true case of opposites, but rather an example of “similar, but different.” For this, the transition between the two groups of dancers feels more like a novelty and less like a choice made in service of the piece, even if each section is strong in silo.

Alexander Swader in “Brigid” by Noelle Kayser, Julie Kent, and Heather Sielaff. Photograph by Troy Schumacher

Alexander Swader in “Brigid” by Noelle Kayser, Julie Kent, and Heather Sielaff. Photograph by Troy Schumacher

The next piece, “The Wet Heat of Living,” choreographed by Shane Urton to a composition by Paul Novak and inspired by a poem by M. Soledad Caballero, avoids this challenge by casting only contemporary dancers, Hogan, Kappa, Lyte, Swader, and Brooke Lutz. This one, Urton writes in the program notes, follows “five forgotten Frankenstein monsters on a journey from eerie boredom to tender dance theater.” 

Indeed, the dancers do move a touch ghoulishly, while lines from Caballero’s poetry are read over piano and percussion. One dancer crawls as the others cluster together like a multi-limbed organism. As they reach for one another, they move in slow motion. They are connected, but not in a way that reads quite human—there is something discordant in their touch and in the blankness of their eyes.

As the dancers pick up their pace, they gain a pleasing momentum that takes them through articulate phrases of turns and tumbles. But this speed is only temporary; they repeatedly, independently fall apart. One particularly memorable moment brings every dancer to run and slide onto their back in the middle of the stage, as the others move in circles around them. The piece ends with a pas de deux between Hogan and Swader, as the other three dancers watch from the sidelines. They reach their arms in pleading gestures, facing one another but casting their eyes away. Their movements are bids for connection, and by the end, the two fall into a proper dialogue, reacting to each other’s shifts of weight with attention and care.

Keenan Kiefer, Alexander Perone, Ella Titus, Arayah Lyte, Georgia Greene in “What If, For a Day, We Could Be Friends” by Troy Schumacher. Photograph by Steven Pisano

Keenan Kiefer, Alexander Perone, Ella Titus, Arayah Lyte, Georgia Greene in “What If, For a Day, We Could Be Friends” by Troy Schumacher. Photograph by Steven Pisano

With his piece “What If, For a Day, We Could Be Friends,” BalletCollective founder and artistic director Troy Schumacher delivers the clearest execution of the night’s theme. The full-company cast of eleven dancers is divided into birds and bugs (or perhaps lizards?), dressed in vivid, patterned costumes by Christian Joy that are, in their earnestness, delightfully campy. A score by Phong Tran, performed by the phenomenal saxophone quartet ~Nois, makes this work the most melodic of the night.

Here, there is no neat division of contemporary and classical dancers. As a result, the piece feels more cohesive, even with Titus and Milić as the only dancers on pointe.

Schumacher does not shy away from cuteness, as evidenced by the more animalistic interactions between the two factions; the bugs crawl around and the birds hold their arms aloft, craning their necks to look curiously at the creatures on the floor. Still, the choreography is technically demanding and provides ample opportunity for the dancers to show off their polished petit allegro and musicality. New York City Ballet corps member Perone particularly stands out with his easeful jumps; Milić, too, is sharp in her footwork and elegant in an adagio moment.

When the whole company comes together—birds and bugs speaking the same choreographic language as they swing a leg forward in attitude devant and rotate in soutenu—it’s a bit frenzied, though it’s undeniably fun to watch.

Rebecca Deczynski


Rebecca Deczynski is a New York City-based writer and editor publishes the newsletter Mezzanine Society. Her work has appeared in publications including Inc., Domino, NYLON, and InStyle. She graduated from Barnard College cum laude with a degree in English and a minor in dance.

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

comments

Veuillez noter que les commentaires doivent être approvés avant d'être affichés

Featured

Washington Ballet Turns 50
REVIEWS | Martha Anne Toll

Washington Ballet Turns 50

One of the first ballets I saw was the Pennsylvania Ballet’s (now Philadelphia Ballet) production of “Carmina Burana,” choreography by John Butler, music by Carl Orff. I don’t think I was more than seven years old, but it was permanently imprinted on me.

Plus
Timeless Beauty
BOOKSHELF | Robert Steven Mack

Timeless Beauty

When Alexei Ratmansky embarked on his historical reconstruction of “The Sleeping Beauty” for American Ballet Theatre in 2015, he bid dancers to lower their leg extensions, perform chaînés en demi-pointe, and adopt a rounder, softer style.

Plus
Creature Comforts
REVIEWS | Rebecca Deczynski

Creature Comforts

How do you translate a scent into dance? A poem? An illustration? In BalletCollective’s 15th anniversary season, the company’s ambition to push beyond expected parameters of ballet is expressed in three world-premiere works.

Plus
Good Subscription Agency