This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Home and Away

It is always interesting when multiple theme steps emerge over the course of a mixed repertory evening, but it is uncanny on one featuring five different ballets, each with a different choreographer and composer, covering a twenty-year span (2005-2025). Yet oddly enough, some unusual steps popped up with surprising regularity under those conditions on the opening night of the Dutch National Ballet’s City Center run. There was the squat scoot: a partnered plié spin in second position. There were lots of wide, forced arch stances as well as hands-on-thighs power struts. And in a few works, people lay upon each other facing upright like stacked sardines. These were weird congruities on a scattered, but impressively danced, program. After an absence of forty years, the Dutch National Ballet proved that they have top tier talent despite choreography that was strangely repetitive yet not cohesive.

Performance

Dutch National Ballet: Ted Brandsen’s “The Chairman Dances” / Wubkje Kuindersma’s “Two and Only” / Hans Van Manen’s “Frank Bridge Variations” / Alexei Ratmansky “Trio Kagel” /  Jerome Robbins’s “Other Dances” 

Place

New York City Center, New York, NY, November 2025

Words

Faye Arthurs

Olga Smirnova and Jacopo Tissi in Jerome Robbins’s “Other Dances.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

subscribe to the latest in dance


“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

The US premiere of Ted Brandsen’s “The Chairman Dances,” set to John Adams’s pulsing, cinematic score of the same name, started the night off strong. Nine couples wore identical long, sheer, white gowns by François-Noël Cherpin that evoked George Balanchine’s “Serenade.” (A few choreographic arm quotes solidified the link.) The vocabulary ranged from chugging wedges and ballroom waltzes to explosive lifts in Busby Berkely blooms. There were breakout solos, duets, quartets, sextets, and pas de deux so that every member of the large cast had a shining moment. It wound down with the group switching from unison work to ball-change backbends with popcorn timing until one woman was left onstage alone as it began. There was no grand message, but it was energizing and showed off the tight synchronization and athleticism of the troupe.

After a pause, the NY premiere of Wubkje Kuindersma’s “Two and Only” brought the energy level down, though movements didn’t slow down any. Michael Benjamin sang and played his own lilting songs in the front corner of the stage, first on guitar and then on piano. Timothy Van Pouke and Conor Walmsley, topless with matching black pants, acted out the ups and downs of a past relationship. The men danced beautifully, though their finicky choreography and sleek styling was often at odds with the rusticity of Benjamin’s timbre and verse. Geometric arms and rapid-fire petit allegro duets clashed with drawled bits like “darlin’” and “take heed.”

Dutch National Ballet in Ted Brandsen's “The Chairman Dances.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

The closing dance on the program, the NY premiere of Hans Van Manen’s “Frank Bridge Variations,” also had a mismatch between the music, the costumes, and the steps. Set to Benjamin Britten’s compositions, a small cast took on the score’s big emotions wearing simple unitards (by Keso Dekker) and flat shoes. The dark outfits and lighting, by Bert Dalhuysen, made the dancing feel a bit sleepy. Slow pedestrian walking in group patterns featured the hands-on-thighs motif, as if the dancers were roaming dark alleys with their hands in jean pockets.  That they were in matching unitards made it peculiar, however. The pacing was somehow ponderous even when the excellent leads were doing flashy solos. Qian Liu and Young Gyu Choi were a taffy-like pair, and Constantine Allen was terrific in a speedy emboîté variation. 

Luckily, music, choreography, and staging very much aligned earlier in the program, in the US premiere of Alexei Ratmansky’s surreal “Trio Kagel.” This pas de trois was set to the accordion compositions of Mauricio Kagel, played lived by Vincent Van Amsterdam, who strolled in through the circus-styled wings and sat on a purple fringed tuffet. The bizarro humor was immediately apparent, then quickly reinforced by the vampy entrance of the spectacular dancers Kira Hilli, Lore Zonderman, and Giorgi Potskhishvili. They performed many challenging turn passages in between angry double fist punches, forward-falling arabesques with cocked heads, and pouty flops to the floor. The women were costumed like goth Harlequin dolls, and Potskhishvili evoked Siegfried and Roy in his sequined white vest and black velvet pants (by Dekker again). In a way, Hill and Zonderman resembled petulant, yet fierce, tigresses. They also gave off creepy, twin vibes à la The Shining

Dutch National Ballet in Alexei Ratmansky’s “Trio Kagel.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

As in Ratmansky’s “Odesa,” the “Trio Kagel” vibe skewed sleazy. But it conjured a carny sideshow instead of a small-town mafia. It also vacillated between jokey—as when Hilli did the running man on pointe, or scooted offstage backwards on her butt—and eerie. I liked when all the dancers buzzed menacingly in bourées then plopped nonchalantly to fifth. I also enjoyed Zonderman’s hard-hitting leaping solo. Throughout, the dancers did an amazing job of clearing Ratmansky’s technical hurdles while keeping up their moue chic. Potshkhishvili was wizardly in his fiendish three-ring feats. His pandering, choreographed bows midway through the dance deserved the copious applause they solicited. There’s no danger of “Trio” cracking my favorite Ratmansky ballet list, but it was well-constructed and incredibly entertaining.

Olga Smirnova and Jacopo Tissi in Jerome Robbins’s “Other Dances.” Photograph by Steven Pisano

The dancers that everyone had come to see, the former Bolshoi stars Olga Smirnova and Jacopo Tissi, closed out the first half of the program in Jerome Robbins’s “Other Dances.” The fact that this ballet was made in 1976 for the earlier Russian company defectors Natalia Makarova and Mikhail Baryshinokov gave it a world-weary lens, and it felt heavier and even more hushed than usual in pianist Ryoko Kondo’s extremely slow interpretation of the Chopin selections. Smirnova seemed more comfortable moving at a snail’s pace than Tissi. He didn’t appear to be dancing so much as focusing on not falling over, especially in the exposed transitions in his adagio variation.    

Smirnova, however, made the most of her extra stage time, luxuriating in every folksy arm flourish. Though a hitch-kick was laborious at that tempo, she milked it, bending way back into a layout after landing. And her long, hyperextended arms are still fascinating to me. She locks her elbows so that they jut out backwards, like bird leg joints. Yet somehow, they move fluidly overall. She trails her arms behind her torso like a swan too, giving the sweeping impression of a large wingspan. Improbably, she broadcasts power and delicacy simultaneously. She was controlled in her difficult passé balances, yet she had a demure mien even when posing boldly. When she decadently brought her hand to the back of her head and tilted back ever so slowly on the last note of a solo, everyone seemed to sigh and lean with her in the audience. Unlike many of the pieces on the program, she seemed to have a strong point of view and the means to get it across. 

Faye Arthurs


Faye Arthurs is a former ballet dancer with New York City Ballet. She chronicled her time as a professional dancer in her blog Thoughts from the Paint. She graduated summa cum laude with a B.A. in English from Fordham University. She lives in Brooklyn with her partner and their sons.

comments

Featured

Green Light
REVIEWS | Sarah Cecilia Bukowski

Green Light

Will Rawls makes boundaries visible by defying them. Known for the disciplinary and topical range of his projects, the choreographer, director, and performer approaches issues of representation in “[siccer],” a multi-part, multi-site work co-presented by L’Alliance New York’s Crossing the Line Festival. A live performance at Performance Space New York accompanies a multimedia installation at the Kitchen, a book published by Wendy’s Subway, and an album published by the artist. With a creative process reaching back to 2018, the work delves explicitly into pandemic-era energies and inertias with focused intimacy and a pervasive sense of instability.

Continue Reading
Home and Away
REVIEWS | Faye Arthurs

Home and Away

It is always interesting when multiple theme steps emerge over the course of a mixed repertory evening, but it is uncanny on one featuring five different ballets, each with a different choreographer and composer, covering a twenty-year span (2005-2025).

Continue Reading
Of Dandelions and Resilience
REVIEWS | Karen Greenspan

Of Dandelions and Resilience

Zvidance premiered its new work “Dandelion” mid-November at New York Live Arts. Founded by Zvi Gotheiner in 1989, Zvidance has been a steady presence in the New York contemporary dance scene, a reliable source of compositional integrity, and a magnet for wonderful dancers.

Continue Reading
Mastering Misuse with d. Sabela grimes
INTERVIEWS | Victoria Looseleaf

Mastering Misuse with d. Sabela grimes

He’s a choreographer, movement composer and trans-media storyteller: He’s d. Sabela grimes, who grew up in Lompoc, California, and didn’t know that his true calling would be as a dancer, choreographer and teller of tales until he moved to Philadelphia in the late 1990s and met Rennie Harris of Rennie Harris Puremovement.

Continue Reading
Good Subscription Agency