This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Humanity Restored

At the end of Batsheva Dance Company’s “Last Work,” a man sits with his back to us and his legs spread, apparently masturbating. Then he rotates to face us and we see he is cleaning a machine gun. Meanwhile, club music pounds, a frenzied crowd runs in circles, lights flash, streamers fly. Ian Robinson drags out a microphone and starts lashing it to the floor with masking tape. Then he screams.


Batsheva Dance Company: “Last Work”


Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, San Francisco, California, February 16, 2017


Rachel Howard

subscribe to the latest in dance

“Uncommonly intelligent, substantial coverage.”

Your weekly source for world-class dance reviews, interviews, articles, and more.

Already a paid subscriber? Login

And all the while, in the corner, as she has for the entire 70 minutes, a long-haired woman in a blue dress runs on a treadmill. But now she hoists a white flag.

Ohad Naharin has served as artistic director and choreographer of Israel’s Batsheva Dance Company for 27 years. He is, to my mind, one of the world’s two most important living choreographers, alongside William Forsythe. The moments of his work that can best be written about effect you like installation art, drawing you into disturbing ambiguity. You know exactly what you’re seeing, but look at the image one way and it’s hopeful; look at it another way and it’s terrorizing.

Take the final moments of “Last Work,” after Robinson has exhausted himself screaming. The dancers, in white shorts and tank stops, stand scattered, frozen mid-movement, across the stage. Robinson takes the masking tape and wraps it around one dancer’s waist, then stretches it like a vector to the next dancer’s waist, then stretches it to the next dancer, the tape screeching as it’s pulled from the roll, until all 16 dancers stand wrapped in the tape. Is this a vision of the interconnectedness of humanity restored—is each dancer relaxing with relief to have the tape wrapped around her waist? Or is it a spectacle of entrapment, and each dancer is collapsing with resignation? I saw it the first way, my husband saw it the latter. Because the image is both. That’s how poetry works.

What writing about such moments can’t convey is how Naharin builds to them, how his dances don’t just hit you with those images, but draw you into their atmosphere via something it would be cheap to call “pacing,” via a rhythm of tension and release, via subliminally perceived patterns, which is to say through poetic form. The language of his movement poetry is Gaga, the movement vocabulary he’s developed over decades, and in “Last Work” it speaks, as usual, with entrancing texture. Extreme backbends, predatory squats, knees torqued out, pelvis tucked under. Legs and arms extending with equal naturalism and eloquence, feet reaching and grappling like hands.

And of course, inseparable from the movement, the impulse behind it, the awareness of energy in every cell, the rippling of energy through manipulation of time. Near the beginning of “Last Work,” Robinson stands on one leg, a current of control moving from the tip of his head through his shoulder, torso, every leg muscle and toe, a slow-motion whip lash that ever so gradually, mesmerizingly, accelerates until the whip is cracking maniacally. In one of the later sections of “Last Work,” as the dancers cluster, each breaks into a freakishly repeating short phrase that reminded me of watching Internet gifs. Zina Zinchenko has the most awe-inspiring phrase, a drop into a near floor-touching backbend that she lets possess her like an electrical current, and she claims one of the most arresting moments earlier in the dance, too, sitting spread-leg on the floor and then slithering across from right toe to left, in such a way that you look for the snake’s hidden musculature.

The central episode of “Last Work” comes when the dancers assemble in a line at the back of the stage, strip and reclothe in the white shorts and tank tops, while several men don black priestly robes. The duets and trios that follow unfold with novelistic suspense, as the electronic soundtrack by Maxim Warratt, Naharin’s usual collaborator, creeps upon us. None of it reaches the operatic catharsis of Naharin’s “Sadeh21,” which Batsheva brought to San Francisco in 2015; “Last Work” is a slightly cooler odyssey, more reminiscent of Naharin’s “Three,” seen on the West Coast in 2006. I dearly wish I could compare “Last Work” to more of Naharin’s oeuvre (I have seen “Deca Dance” and a few others), but we don’t get to see Batsheva Dance Company as regularly as we should on the West Coast. I am unspeakably grateful to San Francisco Performances for bringing Batsheva when they can.

Batsheva associates in the lobby before “Last Work” were handing out postcards for Mr. Gaga, a documentary on Naharin, screening in New York through early March, and in 28 other U.S. cities this spring. I wouldn’t miss seeing it in San Francisco March 10-16th.

Rachel Howard

Rachel Howard is the former lead dance critic of the San Francisco Chronicle. Her dance writing has also appeared in the New York Times, the Hudson Review, Ballet Review, San Francisco Magazine and Dance Magazine.



India Week
REVIEWS | Karen Greenspan

India Week

On a scorcher of a day in July, New York’s Lincoln Center launched India Week, a cultural extravaganza celebrating the variety and vibrancy of Indian culture. 

Continue Reading
Taylor Made
REVIEWS | Karen Hildebrand

Taylor Made

It’s a treat to see the Paul Taylor Dance Company perform within the close range of the Joyce Theater. (The company typically holds court at the much larger Lincoln Center.) 

Continue Reading
Good Subscription Agency